Sunday, 20 January 2013

Experience and empathy


Some comment has been made following William Hague's statement about the Algeria crisis and, in particular, his specific reference to 'British' hostages. The comments were inevitable and understandable although I don't think for a second Mr Hague doesn't also care about the other foreign nationals caught up in the awful events of the last few days. As the British Foreign Secretary though, the natural focus for his efforts has to be the British nationals.
Having reflected on the terrible events in Glencoe following the avalanche there yesterday the two things collided in my mind.
I know Glencoe well; I have camped and walked there many times; like many others I have gazed silently at the raw beauty of Bidean Nam Bian and on each occasion Psalm 121 has sprung, unbidden into my mind; 'I will lift mine eyes unto the hills; from whence cometh my help'.
Since hearing of the avalanche and especially since hearing of the deaths of four of the six people involved, I have been reflecting upon my experience of that beautiful place and upon how these tragic events will have affected that small community. The climbers may well have been camping in the same place I have camped; they may have walked the same paths I have walked; they may have taken refreshment in the climbers inn, the Clachaig, where I have taken refreshment.
These common experiences with people who have lost their lives in a place they probably loved and doing something they probably loved doing have played upon my mind these last twelve hours and it was this that led me to reflect on the reaction to Mr Hague's comments.
Is it part of our make up as human beings that we are especially concerned with the things to which we can relate?
This might not mean we lack concern for people going through terrible experiences which we struggle to relate to but when we can place ourselves in their own position, whether that be on a remote and snowy Glencoe mountainside; on a crowded football terrace on a sunny Saturday afternoon; in an office block in New York City or even in the trenches of the First World War, is it that we are able to feel empathy or sympathy more easily?
If so, we should not criticise others for being in the same position.
In the meantime, remember the all the people caught up in the terrible events in Algeria, even Mr Hague, and also remember the people whose lives have been touched by the avalanche in Glencoe and, as someone commented on Twitter recently, if you do, pray. And if you don’t, pray anyway.